1.24.2011
not for the faint of heart
Two years after bookmarking Pam's enticing peanut butter cup cake, I finally remembered it at the right time & was able to make it for H's birthday. My husband, when asked what kind of cake he'd like, always responds with the same answer: anything chocolate. And he will never, ever turn away an opportunity to marry chocolate and peanut butter. This cake is a must for anyone who's of the same mind, though be forewarned it is exceedingly indulgent and decadent, and even the most hardcore chocoholic will want to start with a very thin slice.
I made the recipe almost exactly as Pam directed, though I used a slightly different version of the cake. The cake is quite soft & crumbly, so I had to coerce the fudge & buttercream layers into concealing a multitude of craters and cracks in the outer surface. This might work better with a sturdier cake recipe, or even a box mix. If refrigerated, give it a good amount of time to come to room temperature before serving--my fudge layers were still pretty solid when I cut into the cake, which, coupled with the soft cake, meant everyone's plates were a mess when I served them up.
Whew. Just looking at it makes my sweet tooth ache.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)




i am also a fan of chocolate & peanut butter. i've made two versions of this cake and every time it's always been a show stopper. one of my friends actually said he wanted to marry the cake.
ReplyDeleteohhh, yes, I need to make this again! racking my brain for an upcoming special occasion / excuse...
ReplyDeleteThat, right there, is the cake of my dreams.
ReplyDeleteWow, what a fabulous cake!
ReplyDeleteOhhh my gosh! Yummy.
ReplyDeletewoh...that looks amazing!
ReplyDeleteLooks delicious, I may not stop thinking about this cake until I get to try some. Looks like the perfect treat for my prego sweet tooth craving :)
ReplyDeleteThat looks super tasty and absurdly decadent.
ReplyDeleteOMG- I actually gasped when I saw the picture. I wanted to lick my computer screen. (I didn't, though.)
ReplyDeleteOh my lord that looks delicious!
ReplyDeleteYou seriously find the best desserts ever. This one looks like it needs a moment of silence before eating it. :) I've made the caramel cake you posted awhile ago a few times now... yum yum. This one will go on the list!
ReplyDeleteQuestion, just out of curiosity: How do you store your cakes after having a slice or two? I guess it's a good reason to have a lot of people over to enjoy (= less leftovers), but do you have any tips? I need to get a cake stand with a glass cover...
ReplyDeleteThat looks amazing!
ReplyDeleteArghhh... I'm a complete Reese's addict and your cacke looks just amazing. Hopefull you cannot find them in Switzerland otherwise I would not be able to control myself!
ReplyDeletePlease, pretty please, have you saved a slice for me? Promise I will go running after this, just looking at it I can feel the calories... On my ToBake list. Thanks for sharing. And Happy Birthday to your little one.
ReplyDeleteMindy - I've stored this at room temp, because the fudge/ganache layer will turn rock-solid in the refrigerator. The leftovers are still on the cake stand shrouded by a bunch of cling film layers; not the most elegant solution, but I was too lazy to transfer it to my Rubbermaid cake container.
ReplyDeleteOh that looks amazing! I think that will be the cake I bake for my hubby's birthday this year. SWEET!
ReplyDeleteOh no! Dont't you know I'm on a diet at the moment? I can hardly bare to look at it, it makes my mouth water. Ahhhhh! so delicious. Greetings from Germany
ReplyDeletewow. that looks RIDICULOUS! Love it.
ReplyDeleteOMG! I've just bookmarked it too. I love peanut butter and chocolate and while I'm breast feeding it seems I can eat as many calories as I want, thanks :)
ReplyDeleteI just discovered your blog. It's very inspirational! My toddler and I tried to make a cake of our own like yours.
ReplyDeletehttp://montrealzen.com/?p=2942
My mouth is watering. I think I might just have to make this! But it probably won't be as pretty as yours!
ReplyDeletehttp://www.artsintertwined.com
I am requesting this cake for my birthday. I may have to make it myself but that's okay... Found it on Pinterest.com fyi. Not sure if you knew you were being pinned (I would consider it a great honor myself!)
ReplyDeleteI'm new Pinterest! Just found this cake, looks delicious! Where do I find the recipe?
ReplyDeleteWhere an I find the recipe? Also new to pinterest.
ReplyDeleteHi there - the links to a couple of cake recipes are within the post.
ReplyDeleteTrying to get the recipie...found on pinterest.
ReplyDeleteI would love the recipe too!!! It looks yummy:)
ReplyDeleteI would like the recipe...where do I find it??
ReplyDeleteI'm sorry some of you are having trouble finding the recipe in the post; it's linked above as "Pam's cake". You can also copy and paste this into your browser's URL field: http://www.flickr.com/photos/pamelawynne/3598206627/.
ReplyDeletethis is probally a stupid question, lol but do you use a cake mix, or a made from scratch mix, i didn't see a cake mix, or recipe for one?
ReplyDeletethe recipes are in the description. :)
ReplyDelete